True cod means fish in the genus Gadus, family Gadidae — primarily Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua), Pacific cod (Gadus macrocephalus), and Greenland cod (Gadus ogac). But at least five more species sell under the "cod" name without belonging to that family at all — most notably black cod, also called sablefish. Understanding that distinction is the only reliable way to avoid buying the wrong fish.

What Is Cod, Exactly?

Cod is the common name for cold-water, white-fleshed marine fish in the Gadidae family of the Northern Hemisphere. The group shares a profile: white, lean flesh with fine flakes, low fat content, and a mild flavor.

The complication is that "cod" is a broad market name. It gets applied to species that aren't cod at all, in English just as much as in other languages.

Scientifically, the tiers work like this:

  • True cod = species in the genus Gadus
  • The cod family (Gadidae) = broader, also covering haddock, whiting, pollock, and saithe
  • "Cod" as a market name = broadest of all, stretching to species from entirely different families, like sablefish

That gap between the scientific tier and the market tier is where nearly every mislabeling problem originates.

How Many Types of Cod Are There?

Group

Definition

Common species

Widely sold?

Group 1 — True cod

Genus Gadus, family Gadidae

Atlantic cod, Pacific cod, Greenland cod

✅ Yes

Group 2 — Close relatives

Family Gadidae, different genus

Haddock, Alaska pollock, saithe/coalfish, whiting

✅ Yes

Group 3 — "Cod" in name only

Market name includes "cod," family is entirely different

Sablefish (black cod), lingcod, rock cod

✅ Sablefish especially

The key point: black cod — the most premium and most expensive fish on this list — isn't true cod at all. It belongs to Anoplopomatidae, a completely separate family.

Species ID Table — 8 Fish Sold as "Cod"

Use the scientific name as your reference. Common names and market names both drift.

Common name

Market name

Scientific name

Family

How to identify

Black cod

Sablefish

Anoplopoma fimbria

Anoplopomatidae

Black skin with blue sheen, white marbling, rich buttery flesh, highest price

Pacific cod

True cod, gray cod

Gadus macrocephalus

Gadidae
 

Mottled gray-brown skin, lean white flesh, chin barbel

Atlantic cod

Cod, scrod

Gadus morhua

Gadidae

Pale lateral line, chin barbel, lean white flesh

Greenland cod

Ogac

Gadus ogac

Gadidae

Smaller, Arctic range, rarely traded commercially

Alaska pollock

Pollock

Gadus chalcogrammus

Gadidae

Fine white flesh, very lean, primary surimi raw material

Haddock

Haddock

Melanogrammus aeglefinus

Gadidae

Dark shoulder patch, finer flake than cod

Saithe

Coalfish, pollock

Pollachius virens

Gadidae

Dark back, grayish raw flesh that whitens when cooked

Lingcod Lingcod

Ophiodon elongatus

Hexagrammidae

Large head and mouth, flesh sometimes naturally blue-green

Sources: FishBase, NOAA Fisheries, Alaska Department of Fish and Game.

Two name collisions worth knowing:

  • Sablefish vs. saithe. Saithe's English market name is "coalfish," which translates into several languages as something close to "coal cod" — colliding directly with an alternate name for sablefish in Vietnamese. Completely different fish, completely different price tier.
  • "Pollock" means two fish. Both Gadus chalcogrammus (Alaska pollock) and Pollachius virens (saithe) trade as "pollock" depending on the market.

What Is Black Cod and Why Is It Its Own Category?

Black cod (Anoplopoma fimbria) isn't in the cod family. It carries the "cod" name for commercial reasons. It belongs to Anoplopomatidae, lives only in the North Pacific at depths of 300 to 1,500 meters, and can live more than 90 years.

Why it stands apart and commands the highest price on this list:

  • Far higher fat content: roughly 15.3g per 100g, versus 0.4–0.6g in true cod
  • Very high omega-3s: about 1,790mg of EPA+DHA per 100g, in salmon territory
  • A completely different texture: silky, buttery, large-flaked, where true cod is firm, lean, and fine-flaked
  • Limited stock, difficult harvest: longline-caught in deep water and managed under individual quotas

Short version: black cod and true cod share white flesh and nothing else. Full breakdown in our guide to black cod vs. regular cod.

Atlantic Cod vs. Pacific Cod

Both are true cod, nearly interchangeable in the kitchen, but they differ in waters and stock status.

Factor

Atlantic cod

Pacific cod

Scientific name

Gadus morhua

Gadus macrocephalus

Waters

North Atlantic (Norway, Iceland, Canada)

North Pacific (Alaska, Japan, Russia)

Typical size

Larger

Smaller, proportionally larger head

Texture

Slightly larger flake, moister

Firmer, finer flake

Moisture Higher

Lower — better for frying

Stock status

Historically depleted, recovering in some areas

Stable and well-managed in Alaska

Relative price

Higher

More affordable

For home cooks: the sensory gap between them is small. Pacific cod is usually the more practical pick — steady supply, strong sustainability management out of Alaska, and better value. See our Pacific cod selection.

Label Cross-Reference — Avoiding Mislabeled Fish

Match the name on the label against the scientific name. If they don't line up with this table, ask.

If the label says...

The scientific name must be...

If it isn't, it's...

Black cod / sablefish

Anoplopoma fimbria

A different species — red flag

Pacific cod

Gadus macrocephalus

A different species — red flag

Atlantic cod

Gadus morhua

A different species — red flag

Alaska pollock

Gadus chalcogrammus

Possibly Pollachius virens — ask

Sablefish

Anoplopoma fimbria

The most reliable name of the set

Practical tip: on an import carton, the English trade name and the FAO catch area code are your two most trustworthy data points. Real sablefish always carries FAO Area 67 (Northeast Pacific). If a product labeled "black cod" shows FAO Area 27 (Northeast Atlantic), it's a different fish, full stop.

Full verification walkthrough in our guide on how to pick good black cod.

Which Cod Should You Buy?

Choose by dish and budget, not by name.

  • Rich dishes — broiled, braised, or seared → black cod. It stays moist even if you overcook it. See Alaskan black cod.

  • Lean applications — fish & chips, soups, stews → Pacific cod. Clean flavor that won't make a broth greasy.

  • Volume cooking and fish cakes → Alaska pollock. Fine white flesh that binds well and costs less.

  • Meals for kids and older adults → steamed black cod. Soft, few pin bones, DHA-dense.

Detailed nutrition comparisons in black cod calories and nutrition. Recipes at how to cook black cod. Full range at imported Alaskan fish.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is black cod actually cod? Scientifically, no. Black cod (Anoplopoma fimbria) belongs to the Anoplopomatidae family, not Gadidae. The name is a market convention from the early 1900s — white flesh sold better under a familiar name.

Is sablefish the same as black cod? Yes. Sablefish is the official name; black cod is the market name. Don't confuse either with saithe or coalfish, which are unrelated.

Is pollock a type of cod? Alaska pollock (Gadus chalcogrammus) sits in the same genus as true cod, so it's a very close relative. But it's used differently in the kitchen — mostly for surimi, fish cakes, and processed products.

Which type of cod tastes best? There's no single answer. Black cod is the richest and silkiest, and priced accordingly. But for battered fish or a clear soup, Pacific cod's lean, firm flesh works better.

Is Atlantic cod overfished? Several Atlantic cod stocks collapsed during the 20th century and are under recovery management in various regions. Alaska's Pacific cod stocks are currently assessed as stable and tightly managed.